Can Eve have made a wise choice when there was not yet any agency? We had this lesson in RS today where they asked if Adam and Eve were great and noble spirits, how could they have made such a big mistake? The answer presented is that it wasn’t a mistake.
I think this is one of those things. Like the story of Joseph being sold by his brothers, or of Nephi having to slay Laban. I say just because things turned out well doesn’t mean the situation wasn’t bad. Did God want Jerusalem to have to be destroyed because of their rejection of the prophets? Does he want us to be torn apart if we do not repent, as is mentioned in 3 Nephi?
I think part of God’s power is that nothing can thwart his purpose. But there is opposition in all things.